Below are the storm totals for winter storm Claire. I measured 4 inches in Avon, which is consistent with what's reported from the National Weather Service. So the verdict on best forecasts?
National Weather Service had the most accurate longer range forecast amounts, predicting 4-8 inches about 72 hours prior to the storm arriving. Accuweather predicted 1-3 inches. All other sites I reviewed weren't able to predict an amount at that point.
Strangely, NWS removed their prediction at about 48 hours out from the storm. Accuweather predicted 3-6 inches with 4.3 inches for Avon. WFSB predicted 5-10 inches and Fox predicted 6-12 inches. Weather Channel predicted 1-3 inches. Other sites didn't provide any prediction. The clear winner 48 hours prior to the storms arrival is Accuweather.
Many sites came together at the 24 hour mark, predicting about 2-6 inches.
Winner: Accuweather.
While NWS had a better long term forecast in this instance, they seemed to back off a little, whereas Accuweather's overall provided a more consistent, and ultimately, accurate forecast in this case.
Herer are the storm totals for Claire from the National Weather Service:
PUBLIC INFORMATION STATEMENT
SPOTTER REPORTS
NATIONAL WEATHER SERVICE TAUNTON MA
545 PM EST FRI JAN 21 2011
THE FOLLOWING ARE UNOFFICIAL OBSERVATIONS TAKEN DURING THE PAST 33 HOURS
FOR THE STORM THAT HAS BEEN AFFECTING OUR REGION. APPRECIATION IS EXTENDED
TO HIGHWAY DEPARTMENTS...COOPERATIVE OBSERVERS...SKYWARN SPOTTERS
AND MEDIA FOR THESE REPORTS. THIS SUMMARY IS ALSO AVAILABLE ON OUR
HOME PAGE AT WEATHER.GOV/BOSTON
********************STORM TOTAL SNOWFALL********************
LOCATION STORM TOTAL TIME/DATE COMMENTS
SNOWFALL OF
/INCHES/ MEASUREMENT
CONNECTICUT
...HARTFORD COUNTY...
SIMSBURY 6.0 829 AM 1/21 HAM RADIO
WINDSOR LOCKS 5.6 120 PM 1/21 BRADLEY AIRPORT
SUFFIELD 5.2 843 AM 1/21 HAM RADIO
MANCHESTER 5.0 1041 AM 1/21 HAM RADIO
SOUTH WINDSOR 5.0 1138 AM 1/21
WEST HARTFORD 4.8 906 AM 1/21 HAM RADIO
BURLINGTON 4.7 954 AM 1/21 TRAINED SPOTTER
2 SW GRANBY 4.5 951 AM 1/21 NWS EMPLOYEE
ENFIELD 4.5 1042 AM 1/21 HAM RADIO
EAST HARTFORD 4.5 1037 AM 1/21 HAM RADIO
WETHERSFIELD 4.0 1045 AM 1/21 HAM RADIO
AVON 4.0 1015 AM 1/21
SOUTHINGTON 3.0 837 AM 1/21 HAM RADIO
...TOLLAND COUNTY...
TOLLAND 6.5 1233 PM 1/21
STORRS 6.5 910 AM 1/21 TRAINED SPOTTER
COVENTRY 6.0 1229 PM 1/21 HAM RADIO
STAFFORDVILLE 6.0 1101 AM 1/21 COOP OBSERVER
STAFFORD SPRINGS 5.6 1122 AM 1/21
ELLINGTON 5.0 1039 AM 1/21 HAM RADIO
VERNON 4.1 1038 AM 1/21 HAM RADIO
...WINDHAM COUNTY...
ASHFORD 7.0 1100 AM 1/21 HAM RADIO
EAST KILLINGLY 6.1 248 PM 1/21
WOODSTOCK 5.8 912 AM 1/21 HAM RADIO
BROOKLYN 5.8 1117 AM 1/21 HAM RADIO
PLAINFIELD 5.5 1154 AM 1/21 HAM RADIO
MOOSUP 5.2 1118 AM 1/21 GENERAL PUBLIC